Differences from other automation systems in the energy industry
SCADA systems are just one option within the entire industrial automation ecosystem, and while they share certain functions with other technologies, they have key differences in their approach and application.
SCADA and Manufacturing Execution System (MES)
One of the systems that is often compared to SCADA is the Manufacturing Execution System (MES), a technology focused on managing and optimising production within industrial environments. It interconnects all levels of production plants to calculate the efficiency of operations and improve efficiency. It also facilitates the ability to anticipate future issues with a constant information flow from real-time data collection.
Both are systems that can complement each other, improving process performance. SCADA provides operational data and MES uses it to improve planning and strategic decision making. Their current applications are a clear example of this difference: SCADA is common in areas such as power grids, wind farms and substations where it is essential to react immediately to changes or failures, while MES is often used in factories producing electrical components, batteries or turbines, where the aim is to improve productivity and reduce waste.
SCADA and Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs)
Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs) are physical devices that execute programmed instructions to control specific processes, such as activating a turbine or regulating the voltage in a substation. SCADA can manage and supervise multiple PLCs within a network to enable constant monitoring and remote control.
A practical example in the power sector is when SCADA is used to monitor an entire electricity distribution grid, while PLCs control individual circuit breakers and transformers within the grid.
SCADA and Distributed Control Systems (DCS)
Distributed Control Systems (DCS) allow processes to be managed by controllers distributed throughout an installation and connected via a communication network. They make it possible to manage a large number of control points, making them useful in large and complex plants.
In power, SCADA and DCS are applied in different ways. While SCADA gives the possibility of managing several connected solar plants in different applications, the DCS system controls the internal processes in a single power plant.
SCADA and Energy Management System (EMS)
Energy Management Systems (EMS) optimise energy consumption, distribution and generation. With them you can analyse patterns and make decisions on how a factory can be more efficient and reduce costs.
In power, EMS takes a more panoramic view. For example, SCADA monitors a power grid and can detect a voltage drop in a substation, sending an order to activate a backup source and prevent a blackout. However, EMS analyses operational data (including data collected by SCADA) and allows redistribution of the electrical load from one generation plant to another to maximise efficiency. Both systems can be integrated at the same time.